Police Scotland have been accused of acting as Donald Trump’s private security force after charging a 61-year-old woman for allegedly answering the call of nature amongst the dunes at the would-be US president’s golf resort in Aberdeenshire.
Rohan Beyts, an endurance swimmer, mountain climber and former social worker, has been charged under section 47 of the Civic Government Act (Scotland) 1982 for urinating “in such circumstances as to cause, or to be likely to cause, annoyance to any other person”. If convicted, she could be fined up to £500.
She said she was visited by police at 10pm on Thursday night after a complaint from the Trump organisation. Police officers told her that Trump staff had photographed her on mobile phones committing the alleged offence late in the afternoon on 11 April.
“There was no-one in view when I – and I am not admitting anything – sat down in the dunes which suggests that they were keeping out of sight,” she said.
“I was doing nothing wrong. Actions like this are designed to intimidate. I’ve nothing to be ashamed or embarrassed about.”
She was accused by the Trump organisation, however, of causing offence. “Offensive behaviour such as this is a matter for the police,” said Trump’s Scottish spokeswoman, Sarah Malone.
Actions like this are designed to intimidate. I've nothing to be ashamed or embarrassed about. Rohan Beyts
“This disgusting and shameful act took place in broad daylight in full view of our staff and guests by an individual who has been disruptive in the past.”
Beyts said she had never been charged with any offence before. She is an active environmentalist and has protested against Trump’s golf course in the past.
She does voluntary work for the John Muir Trust, which protects wild land – including clearing up other people’s wastes. She famously swam the Gulf of Corryvreckan, site of the world’s third largest whirlpool, to raise money for the trust in 2011.
When she does have to relieve herself while out walking she follows the Mountaineering Council of Scotland’s advice on “where to go in the great outdoors”, she said.
Beyts accepted that the police have to follow up complaints of alleged wrongdoing. “But they came to my home at 10pm regarding what is essentially a minor offence,” she said. “My first thought was that something had happened to one of my children and this caused me a lot of distress.”
The filmmaker, Anthony Baxter, was arrested by police in 2010 when he was making a documentary about the way Trump treated local residents. “The police are once again behaving like a private security force for Donald Trump,” he said. “What a complete waste of police time and resources.”
He added: “This is a sorry reminder that Trump’s luxury golf development is a gated community for the super rich where ordinary people are not welcome. Spying Trump cameras and security guards keep a watch on what was once a wilderness area of outstanding natural beauty.”
The Scottish Greens accused Trump of “bullying and heavy-handedness”. The party’s justice spokesperson and former police officer, John Finnie, urged Police Scotland to drop the charge.
The police are once again behaving like a private security force for Donald Trump. Anthony Baxter, filmmaker
After Beyts told her story on social media, she received dozens of messages of support. “You are wonderful granny Beyts,” said Rosanne McWilliams. “May your piss flow long and amber for many moons to come…God love ya.”
Davie Newton said: “A mass act of pissing disobedience might be in order if this is actually taken to court. Polis should be ashamed as should the folk that sent them to you.”
“Few folk will not have had cause to take a comfort break and, so long as appropriate steps are taken to ensure privacy, there should be no issue,” he said.
“The police should reflect on their actions. If the matter is reported further then the Fiscal should place the report in the bin and have a word in the lug of the officers involved.
“Hopefully, after reflecting, the authorities will share my opinion that the more appropriate recipients of police attention are those who think it acceptable to film someone taking a discrete comfort break.”
Police Scotland confirmed that Beyts had been charged under section 47 of the Civic Government Act (Scotland) 1982. “Police Scotland has a responsibility to investigate any and all reports of criminal activity,” said a police spokeswoman.
“Police Scotland can confirm that a 61 year old woman has been charged in connection with an incident at Trump International Golf Links, Balmedie, Aberdeen on April 11. A report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.”
Read updates on this story here and here.
A version of this story was published in the Sunday Herald on 17 April 2016.
Cover image thanks to Gage Skidmore, Peoria, AZ, US, Donald Trump, CC BY-SA 2.0.
Photo of Rohan Beyts thanks to Rory Syme/John Muir Trust.
Is it any coincidence that D. Trump’s surname embraces a synonym for arse?
Hmm. I suppose a mass piss is in dubious taste?
Such a shame that the local law enforcement agency does not have pride & integrity of their heritage & community – do their children attend private schools?? History records another egotistical narcissist whom used the same tactics, just change the colour of the Don’s hair & grow a few dark hairs on his top lip??? It’s hard to keep on while enduring a psychological battle, just know that you are supported by another from down under & God help the world if he leaves his tower to a big white house
I am sure that a quick look at the bookings on the day in question will prove that nothing wrong was done in front of no people whatsoever……..apart from the three members of staff who were hiding in the bushes to take photos of unsuspecting women.
Someone should be charged with taking rude pictures of people. Is it mid-summer’s day for the dunes mass piss-in?
More a case of ‘taking the piss’ if this goes to court: Update?
The latest update is here: https://droppings.theferret.scot/post/146201644844/challenge-to-warning-for-peeing-at-trump-golf
They were staff filming what appeared to be a anti-social if not criminal act. There is no way they could have known she had a medical condition. I also dislike Donald Trump however I can’t see why this has become a court case.
The nemesis of most walkers – the Golf Course!
I always feel rather intimidated when passing through/near these places, why don’t they always provide a fully segregated and screened clearly defined walkway, to keep walkers and Golfers happy – I don’t understand Golf and Its rules so conflicts are bound to occur occasionally…
Anyway, anyone who walks or cycles for more than a few hours is going to need to relieve themselves from time to time, and you cannot always rely on a convenient convenience – sometimes it is hard to find adequate screening from others – when you gotta go, you gotta go, but I always try to be as discrete as possible as Rohan would have been. I deeply resent people thinking they own the countryside – it belongs to all of us, not just Golfers.
If I was photographed/videod having a call of nature, I would accuse those people of being perverts and expect the police to make them delete the footage.